A reader has credit cards with no balances. Should she close them or keep them?
Question: I have had several credit card companies deny my request for decreasing my APR on purchases. If I choose to close these accounts, which have no balance on them at this time, how will it affect my FICO Score?
— Lynn in South Carolina
Howard Dvorkin CPA answers…
In the complex world of credit cards and credit scores, seldom can I answer so directly, “Don’t do that.” This is one of those times. Let me explain why.
Your credit score is based on five factors, and each one comprises a different amount of your overall score:
- Payment history is 35 percent of your total score
- Credit utilization is 30 percent
- Length of credit history is 15 percent
- New credit is 10 percent
- Credit mix is 10 percent
I know what you’re thinking, Lynn: “What does this have to do with my question?”
Well, if you close credit cards that have zero balances, that affects your credit utilization. That’s a fancy way of saying, “compare the amount of debt you owe to the credit you have available.”
For instance, if you owe $10,000 on your credit cards but have a $100,000 credit limit, that’s better than owing $1,000 — but having only a $1,500 credit limit.
So if you close credit cards that have no balances, you’re surrendering part of your credit utilization ratio. Since that comprises nearly a third of your score, it’s not a small thing.
Then there’s length of credit history. This measures how long you’ve had your credit cards, on the theory that someone who’s been charging and paying responsibly over time is a good credit risk in the future.
If you’re closing credit card accounts you’ve had for years, you’re sacrificing part of your length of credit history, which represents 15 percent of your credit score.
I’ve simplified this explanation, Lynn, and I urge you to read Debt.com’s report, Understanding Your FICO Credit Score.
A big “if”
Of course, my answer relies on a big assumption: You have zero balances on these cards because you pay your bills in full each month.
As you now know, payment history is the biggest factor in your credit score, at a whopping 35 percent. Paying on time is the most important thing you can do. If you have zero balances on a few cards but big balances on others, and if you’re massively in debt and barely able to make ends meet, you have bigger concerns than bolstering one facet of your credit score.
If this is your situation, the very first thing you should do is seek credit counseling to unravel your debts and figure out a way to financial independence. You should read, What Is Credit Counseling… And Why Do I Need It?
The question you didn’t ask
I’m guessing, Lynn, that you called your credit card company and asked for a lower interest rate because you read something on the topic, either from someone else or from me (Can I Really Request A Break From My Credit Card Company?).
You can be turned down for many reasons, but you can also seek other credit card offers. It may seem odd, but you can open a new card with a lower interest rate from another company, while keeping your existing cards and perhaps charging something every so often.
Once you have your new card(s) for 5-7 years, you can close the old ones with no ding on your FICO score.
To my dedicated readers, this will come as odd advice, since I’ve written in one of my books, “Learning to live without a credit card is an integral part of financial empowerment.” However, if you’re going to keep several cards open, I want you to do it the right way. As always, knowledge is power — but so is self-discipline.
Have a debt question?
Email your question to firstname.lastname@example.org and Howard Dvorkin will review it. Dvorkin is a CPA, chairman of Debt.com, and author of two personal finance books, Credit Hell: How to Dig Yourself Out of Debt and Power Up: Taking Charge of Your Financial Destiny.
Meet the Author
Article last modified on September 4, 2018 Published by Debt.com, LLC . Mobile users may also access the AMP Version: Will Credit Cards I Don't Use Hurt My Credit Score — Or Help It? - AMP.